Quest for Peace Newsletter

Open letter to Ambassador Trivelli

[ Versión Español ]

Quest for Peace and the Nicaragua Network published this letter as an ad in two Nicaraguan newspapers on October 13, 2006. To date, 1072 people have added their signatures:

An open letter to Paul Trivelli, U.S. Ambassador to Nicaragua
from citizens of the United States:

The United States forbids the citizens and governments of other nations from attempting by words and/or funding to influence the way United States citizens cast their votes in national elections. The Vienna Convention's provisions that govern diplomatic behavior prohibit diplomats from interfering in the internal matters of the country to which they are assigned.

Report Back from the Nicaraguan Election Interference Monitoring Delegation

by Tom Loudon, Quest for Peace staff

Our jointly sponsored Quest for Peace and Nicaragua Network delegation recently returned from Nicaragua after a very successful visit. The purpose of our trip was to investigate and monitor the level of illegal U.S. intervention in the Election process underway. Nicaraguans will elect a new president and assembly delegates this coming November 5th, and the U.S. Embassy and other members of the U.S. government have been intervening in the Nicaraguan process in a number of troublesome ways.

The U.S. Ambassador and other State Department officials seem to be completely obsessed with the possibility of Daniel Ortega becoming the next president of Nicaragua. They are apparently only interested in the kind of democracy where their chosen candidate wins. The U.S. Ambassador and other State Department officials seem to be completely obsessed with the possibility of Daniel Ortega becoming the next president of Nicaragua. They are apparently only interested in the kind of democracy where their chosen candidate wins. This obsession has resulted in almost constant illegal and immoral interference in the election process.

The June 2006 delegation reported that "the United States had gone beyond what was appropriate and correct in its involvement in the electoral process." Unfortunately, we found the level of interference continues to be high, and the Ambassador and other functionaries have made repeated statements in favor of Eduardo Montealegre, and against the two front running candidates, Daniel Ortega and Jose Rizo.

While in Nicaragua we met with independent analysts, representatives from the OAS, representatives from four political parties and with human rights organizations.

All expressed a desire for a fair and clean electoral process. Most expressed preoccupation at the way the United States has been interfering.

In a late September visit to Nicaragua, Congressman Dan Burton publicly declared that diplomatic and economic relations with Nicaragua would likely suffer if a candidate unacceptable to the United States were elected. The Ambassador, Paul Trivelli has made similar threats, suggesting that the Millennium Challenge Account funds might be at risk if Daniel Ortega is elected.

Statements of this nature by foreign ‘diplomats' violate international norms and must be categorically condemned. If a foreign government agent attempted to interfere in U.S. elections in this fashion, they would quickly loose their diplomatic status. Statements of preference by foreign ‘diplomats' violate international norms and must be categorically condemned. If a foreign government agent attempted to interfere in U.S. elections in this fashion, they would quickly loose their diplomatic status. Things have been so bad in Nicaragua that the Secretary General of the OAS on a recent visit to Nicaragua specifically asked for foreign officials to stop their illegal and immoral meddling in the affairs of Nicaragua.

Oddly, during the time we were in Nicaragua, which was shortly after the Secretary General had made his remarks, there were no comments by the U.S. Ambassador. He did, however feel it necessary to comment on the open letter which we placed in the two major newspapers, and to the press conference which we held on the day the open letter was published. Click here to see the statement we read. The Embassy's response was published right next to an article the Nuevo Diario ran which covered our press conference from the day before. Essentially the Embassy said that their work was to promote democracy, and they were funding organizations which do that work. They couldn't however, resist plugging their favorite candidate, while at the same time giving their reasons for why the two leading candidates are unacceptable to them. They forgot to mention that their favorite candidate, a banker has been implicated in a major banking scandal which has resulted in over $500 million in debt which the government is paying.

Trivelli's silence during our delegation was short lived. Earlier this week, while at an event with potential investors in Nicaragua he once again renewed his attacks on Daniel Ortega. Trivelli's silence during our delegation was short lived. Earlier this week, while at an event with potential investors in Nicaragua he once again renewed his attacks on Daniel Ortega. He said "the $180 million potential investments that could result from a new agreement called Corporation of Private Investment in the Exterior will not happen if there is not a positive climate towards external investment and private property." He went on to say, "clearly the Nicaraguans will decide who is their next president, but they will have to live with the consequences."

In the decade of the 1980's, the Nicaraguan people suffered the consequences of a brutal Contra war that was sponsored by the United States, in the pursuit of U.S. ‘policy goals' in Nicaragua. Current threats tap into this long, brutal history of U.S. intervention. We must continue to express our outrage at this short-sighted and illegal behavior and support the right to self-determination of the Nicaraguan people. In the next few days we will be asking you to call your Congresspeople and Congressional candidates. Please stay alert for our announcement, and keep checking back for updates on the situation in Nicaragua.

US Embassy Responds to Open Letter to Ambassador Trivelli

published in:
NUEVO DIARIO
10/14/06
Managua, Nicaragua

 see the original article (spanish) - scroll to 2nd half of story

"We will not apologize"

In a response to a letter published by citizens of the United States requesting that Ambassador Trivelli be silent regarding the electoral process, the government of the United States states that it will not apologize for helping to develop democracy.

 In a press release, the diplomatic seat accredited in Managua assured that the U.S. government does not favor any of the five presidential candidates in Nicaragua, a position which contradicts the declarations of Trivelli and of other North American functionaries who have given tacit support to Eduardo Montealegre, because according to them he represents the "anti-pact" group, and have publicly stated their opposition to the PLC and FSLN strong men, Arnoldo Aleman and Daniel Ortega respectively.

 ...the letter continues,

The Embassy of the United States respects the freedom and right of the people who signed the "Open Letter to Ambassador Paul Trivelli" published in the Nuevo Diario and La Prensa to express their points of view openly and frankly.  We would simply like to indicate that the funds that the government of the United States has provided to the government of Nicaragua and non-governmental organizations for the electoral process have been used in a non-partisan manner for activities that include voter registration, technical assistance for the Supreme Electoral Council, domestic and international observation and civic education.

 This program represents the strong commitment that our government has assumed with the Nicaraguan people to hold free, transparent and inclusive elections. 

 As Ambassador Trivelli has stated many times, we have not and will not endorse any specific candidate.  We have not, nor will we finance any political campaign.  And we will not apologize for our efforts to support the development of democracy in Nicaragua.